Apple's HomeView Is a Fine Speaker and a Great Jukebox, Until CarPlay Apps Show Up
The Verge has published a follow-up to its review of Apple's HomeView, the company's first smart display, answering reader questions about how it works as a smart speaker. The verdict: it sounds decent for its size and works well as a touchscreen music controller, but third-party audio apps are a mess.
On sound, the HomeView is closer to the HomePod Mini than to a full-size HomePod or a Sonos One. Against the Mini 2, The Verge found the tabletop HomeView has better bass and is slightly louder, but is less clear and fills a room less well. The display sits over the speaker base and partly covers it, so Apple added an accelerometer that adjusts the EQ as you tilt the screen. It supports Spatial Audio with Dolby Atmos, which the Mini 2 does not. The wall-mounted version has only two drivers and almost no bass, so it is better for talking to a visitor through a video doorbell than for music.
There is no stereo pairing, either. You can group HomeViews with other AirPlay speakers, but you can't pair two together or pair one with a HomePod or Mini. The reviewer's advice is that for $300 and good sound, two Minis in stereo beat a HomeView. The screen is the real draw, acting like a jukebox for changing songs, picking music and browsing podcasts or audiobooks without voice commands.
Handoff works much as on HomePods. In testing it worked with Apple TV, Apple Music, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Pocket Casts, YouTube Music, FaceTime and phone calls, though calls sometimes dropped. Netflix and Amazon Prime Video handed off audio only, though video played in Safari. Handoff is also aggressive if your phone is within a few inches.
The biggest complaint is third-party apps. Instead of building a dedicated HomeView experience, Apple reuses its CarPlay platform, so any audio or video app that supports CarPlay already works. The cost is no search box or keyboard, slower and laggier performance, and a need for your phone and profile on the same Wi-Fi, so only you can use them. The Verge also hit bugs: control screens that didn't appear and an Audible app that often refused to load. Siri also defaults to the HomeView's own speaker for these apps rather than your last-used speakers.
The takeaway: buy a HomeView if you want a touchscreen music controller and use Apple Music, which is the only service anyone in the house can use. If you mostly use Spotify or other apps, or are happy with voice and phone control, a HomePod is the safer pick. The Verge says CarPlay support feels like a stopgap that Apple needs to refine with developers.
Why it matters
Apple's shortcut of reusing CarPlay shows how platform makers can trade polish for speed, which affects how useful a $300 gadget really is. For shoppers, the choice between a smart display and cheaper speakers depends on which music service you actually use.
Key points
- HomeView sounds closest to a HomePod Mini: more bass and louder, but less clear and less room-filling.
- Third-party apps run through CarPlay, so they lack search, are slower and need a user profile.
- Only Apple Music can be used by anyone in the household; two Minis beat HomeView for sound at $300.
Written by the PixelContent newsroom from public reports. Original reporting: The Verge.
More stories
Nintendo Switch 2 Gets a $50 Black Friday Haircut, But Only One Bundle Qualifies
Nintendo is discounting its Switch 2 Mario Kart World bundle by $50 to $499.99 from November 22 through December 5, temporarily reversing a September price hike. The Sports Resort bundle stays at $529.99.
GTA VI finally lands after 13 years, and players are mostly doing chores and birdwatching
Grand Theft Auto VI has launched after 13 years, and fans told the Guardian they are enjoying domestic chores, exploration and a healthier central relationship as much as the crime and chaos.
California AG Subpoenas Nvidia Over Ex-CEO Jensen Huang's Alleged Ties to a Suspected Chinese Spy
California's attorney general subpoenaed Nvidia to probe whether chips or secrets reached China through ex-CEO Jensen Huang's alleged ties to a suspected Chinese spy, and whether investors were misled.
Switch 2 Black Friday: $20 off Donkey Kong Bananza and more big Nintendo games
Nintendo and major retailers are cutting $20 off top Switch 2 games like Donkey Kong Bananza for Black Friday. Some sales end November 29th, while eShop deals run through December 2nd.
Red Cross warns genie is escaping the bottle on autonomous weapons as UN talks stall
The Red Cross and rights groups warn it will soon be too late to regulate autonomous weapons, after a UN Geneva conference only agreed to discuss a regulatory instrument over two more years.
Tamagotchi turns 30: the beeping keychain that made a generation parent pixels
The Verge marks Tamagotchi's 30th anniversary with a Version History episode on the digital pet's origins, versions and engagement tactics, and whether anyone could stand it today. Spoiler: they couldn't.