Binding of Isaac's AI Music Scandal: Tracks Pulled, Steam Reviews Still Furious
The Binding of Isaac: Repentance Plus has been review-bombed on Steam for several days after players found that music in one section of the game was made with generative AI, according to The Verge. Nicalis, Inc., the studio behind the game, has since updated it to remove the offending tracks.
The discovery came from Reddit user ShweetsStuff, who looked at the songs used in a Grand Theft Auto-themed segment. They found several audio files carrying Suno metadata that pointed back to matching tracks on Suno's site.
Creator Edmund McMillen apologized on X and said he "had no idea" the GTA parody used AI-generated music. Nicalis posted on X within hours of the discovery that the generated music files were gone.
There is also a paperwork problem. Valve requires developers to disclose how and when they use generative AI during development, and Nicalis does not appear to have mentioned the AI music anywhere, per The Verge.
The fix has not yet repaired the damage on Steam, where the game is still rated "overwhelmingly negative." On X, users seem more willing to give McMillen the benefit of the doubt. He has been outspoken against AI in game development, and in a 2024 TikTok he called it "uninspired and bland."
The episode shows how touchy the gaming audience is about generative AI. Even a small slice of a long-running game can set off a backlash, and players are checking the files themselves.
Why it matters
Generative AI is spreading through game production, and audiences are policing it closely. Studios that skip disclosure rules, like Valve's requirement on Steam, risk ratings damage that can hit sales long after the content is patched out.
Key points
- Players found Suno metadata in music files from a GTA-themed segment of Repentance Plus.
- Nicalis removed the AI tracks within hours, and Edmund McMillen said he had no idea they were AI-made.
- Steam reviews remain overwhelmingly negative, and Nicalis apparently did not disclose AI use to Valve.
Written by the PixelContent newsroom from public reports. Original reporting: The Verge.
More stories
Nintendo Switch 2 Gets a $50 Black Friday Haircut, But Only One Bundle Qualifies
Nintendo is discounting its Switch 2 Mario Kart World bundle by $50 to $499.99 from November 22 through December 5, temporarily reversing a September price hike. The Sports Resort bundle stays at $529.99.
GTA VI finally lands after 13 years, and players are mostly doing chores and birdwatching
Grand Theft Auto VI has launched after 13 years, and fans told the Guardian they are enjoying domestic chores, exploration and a healthier central relationship as much as the crime and chaos.
California AG Subpoenas Nvidia Over Ex-CEO Jensen Huang's Alleged Ties to a Suspected Chinese Spy
California's attorney general subpoenaed Nvidia to probe whether chips or secrets reached China through ex-CEO Jensen Huang's alleged ties to a suspected Chinese spy, and whether investors were misled.
Switch 2 Black Friday: $20 off Donkey Kong Bananza and more big Nintendo games
Nintendo and major retailers are cutting $20 off top Switch 2 games like Donkey Kong Bananza for Black Friday. Some sales end November 29th, while eShop deals run through December 2nd.
Red Cross warns genie is escaping the bottle on autonomous weapons as UN talks stall
The Red Cross and rights groups warn it will soon be too late to regulate autonomous weapons, after a UN Geneva conference only agreed to discuss a regulatory instrument over two more years.
Tamagotchi turns 30: the beeping keychain that made a generation parent pixels
The Verge marks Tamagotchi's 30th anniversary with a Version History episode on the digital pet's origins, versions and engagement tactics, and whether anyone could stand it today. Spoiler: they couldn't.