Who Owns What? MP Says Channel Islands' Company Register Plans Leave Too Much in the Shadows
Sir Andrew Mitchell, a Westminster MP, has criticised plans by Guernsey and Jersey to widen access to information on who owns and controls companies, saying they "do not go nearly far enough", according to BBC News.
The two islands have set out proposals letting approved applicants, including journalists and academics with a legitimate interest, request ownership data when looking into suspected financial crime. Today, that information is generally limited to law enforcement, regulators and certain regulated businesses running anti-money laundering checks. The plans follow a joint commitment made in December 2023 by Guernsey, Jersey and the Isle of Man to boost transparency.
Sir Andrew, a long-time campaigner for publicly accessible registers, argues the limits could leave national security threats "entirely invisible" to investigators. He described a "catch-22": investigators may need the register to prove wrongdoing in the first place. He also understood that applicants would have to show they could not find the data elsewhere, which he said defeats the object of a register.
That point is where the two islands differ on paper. Jersey's consultation response says applicants would need to show that "all reasonable alternative sources have been exhausted". Guernsey's published response does not explicitly set out the same requirement. Sir Andrew also wants access open to people in other jurisdictions, such as the global south, and wants the data free at the point of access, with fully public registers as the eventual goal.
Both governments pushed back. A Jersey spokesperson said his concerns do not accurately reflect its consultation paper and that the island meets international standards. Deputy Andrew Niles of Guernsey's Policy & Resources Committee pointed to a positive 2025 assessment and said the model is based on one adopted in the EU, balancing access for legitimate investigations with privacy protection for vulnerable individuals.
Why it matters
Offshore financial centres host a lot of corporate structures, so the rules on who can see behind them affect efforts to fight money laundering and dirty money. Tighter or looser access can shape investigators' reach and the reputation of these finance hubs with global markets and regulators.
Key points
- Sir Andrew Mitchell says the Guernsey and Jersey proposals fall well short of real transparency.
- Journalists and academics with a legitimate interest could apply for access, but Jersey expects applicants to exhaust other sources first.
- Both governments reject the criticism and say they meet international standards.
Written by the PixelContent newsroom from public reports. Original reporting: BBC News.
More stories
Mamdani Takes the DealBook Stage to Talk Trump, Wall Street and Wealth Taxes
New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani spoke with Andrew Ross Sorkin at the DealBook Summit about Trump, Wall Street and wealth taxes, according to The New York Times. Details of his remarks were not available.
Anthropic's Record IPO Meets a Wall Street Wobble Over A.I. Spending Fears
Anthropic's record-breaking IPO was followed by a rocky first full trading day as markets fell on worries about A.I. spending, per The New York Times. It highlights a gap between Wall Street and Silicon Valley.
Centrica boss 'hugely concerned' as UK energy bills set for a January jolt
Centrica chief Chris O'Shea says he is 'hugely concerned' about a forecast £443 rise in typical energy bills from January, warning more people will fail or refuse to pay. Campaigners say government help falls short.
Can't Sell? Some Homeowners Are Becoming Accidental Landlords Instead
Some homeowners are renting out their houses instead of selling, using rent to cover mortgage payments, the New York Times reports. The catch: repairs and difficult tenants come with the keys.
California Serves Nvidia a Subpoena Over Possible China Chip Leaks After Huang's Exit
California's attorney general subpoenaed Nvidia to probe whether China obtained advanced chips or confidential information, and whether investors were misled, after CEO Jensen Huang's exit. Shares are down 22% since early November.
Six Under-40 Americans Show Retirement Saving Has More Than One Road
The New York Times profiles six Americans under 40 who are saving for retirement, some by traditional routes and others by their own, despite competing financial pressures.