Appeals Court Says $1.7T Biden-Era Spending Bill Was Passed Unconstitutionally via Proxy Voting
A federal appeals court ruled on Friday that the $1.7 trillion government funding bill Congress passed in 2022, under then-President Joe Biden, was unconstitutional, according to The Hill. The decision came from the New Orleans-based 5th Circuit.
The problem, per the ruling as described by The Hill, was how the bill got through. Lawmakers used a pandemic-era rule that allowed members of Congress to vote by proxy, rather than showing up in person. The court found that process did not square with the Constitution.
The material available so far is thin: the teaser does not spell out what the ruling means for the spending itself, whether the money already flowing under the law is at risk, or what the court's reasoning looked like in detail. Those questions will likely decide how much this matters in practice.
Context helps here. Omnibus funding bills of this size keep federal agencies running, and they tend to be passed under deadline pressure. Proxy voting was introduced during the pandemic so members could participate without traveling or gathering in crowds. Challenges to how a law was passed, rather than what it says, are unusual, which is why a ruling like this draws attention.
Expect the story to move further. Rulings from a federal appeals court can be appealed, and the next steps, whether further review or action from the government, were not detailed in the material we have. We will update as more becomes clear.
Why it matters
A $1.7 trillion funding law underpins how federal agencies operate, so any legal cloud over how it passed raises questions about certainty for budgets and contractors. Markets and taxpayers will want to know whether this stays a procedural dispute or reaches actual spending.
Key points
- The 5th Circuit ruled the 2022 $1.7 trillion funding bill unconstitutional.
- The issue was a pandemic-era rule allowing proxy voting in Congress.
- Practical effects on the spending and any appeal are not yet clear.
Written by the PixelContent newsroom from public reports. Original reporting: The Hill.
More stories
House Democrats Torn: Defund the Iran War Now or Wait Until They Hold the Purse Strings?
House Democrats are split on whether to demand an end to Iran war funding in the lame-duck session, risking a shutdown, or to wait until they control Congress next year, The Hill reports.
Foreign students are skipping US campuses, and colleges are footing a multimillion-dollar bill
New international student enrollment in the US fell 15% this fall after an 18% drop last year, costing colleges millions as visa limits and enforcement worry applicants. The Department of Homeland Security disputes the framing.
Intelligence chief says Putin is 'not America's friend in Ukraine,' even if Trump calls him one
Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton defended Trump calling Putin a 'friend' but said Putin is 'not America's friend in Ukraine,' separating personal rapport from the US-Russia relationship, The Hill reports.
Intelligence chief Clayton tells Americans to expect 'bumps in the road' as aging systems get upgrades
Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton said Americans should prepare for upgrades to aging infrastructure and systems, warning of 'bumps in the road' amid a recent run of outages, The Hill reported.
Intel Chief Clayton Says He Trusts Trump 'Completely' Despite Putin 'Friend' Remark
Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton told CNN he trusts President Trump "completely" after Trump called Vladimir Putin a friend, according to The Hill.
Congress Heads Home for Turkey Break as Leadership Fights Heat Up and Clayton Praises Trump's Talks
Congress left for Thanksgiving recess after a busy week of bills and confirmations, with leadership fights growing as Democrats prepare to take both chambers, The Hill reports. Clayton praised Trump's trilateral talks.